Today's Brief
An editorial · /sources

How we read sources.

PIE pulls from outlets that play three different roles in a story. We mark which is which, and we tell you why. We don't score them.

ROLE 01Fact-establisher

Outlets whose job is to put facts on the public record — wire services, papers of record, beat reporters with sourcing inside the institutions they cover.

When PIE writes 'Treasury raised the rate to 100% on Tuesday,' that sentence is doing what it can do because a wire service or a paper of record reported it first, with named officials. We start here. Most stories load almost all their weight on this layer — the next two layers explain what the fact means, not whether it happened.

Outlets PIE reads in this role
AxiosT1 · independent
Brief-focused, centrist-establishment news. Balances NPR's lean in the fact-establisher bucket.
BBC NewsT1 · independent
International baseline. Rock-solid RSS; framing sits outside the US partisan axis.
NPR NewsT1 · independent
US public media. Reliable RSS with substantial article text. Carries a slight center-left lean — watch for framing bleed into fact-establisher output (decision #29).
ROLE 02Framing outlet

Outlets that declare a politics and write from inside it. They argue, prosecute, and persuade — well, when they're good. We surface them so framings don't come out of nowhere.

Reading Jacobin on tariffs is reading a socialist case for industrial policy. Reading Commentary on Iran is reading the neoconservative case. Both are useful precisely because they're declared. We mark them with a small chip the same color as our framing chips — same vocabulary you've already learned in the story view.

Outlets PIE reads in this role
CommentaryT2 · declared consEnglish
Funded by
Reader and donor-funded magazine; Commentary Inc. (501c3) since 2007.
Owned by
Commentary Inc.
PIEFounding institution of postwar American neoconservatism. Declares its lens; particularly hawkish on Iran, Israel, and US foreign policy.
JacobinT2 · declared progEnglish
Funded by
Reader-funded; quarterly print + web. Bhaskar Sunkara founded 2010.
Owned by
Independent (Bhaskar Sunkara, majority)
PIEDeclares a socialist editorial line. Writes from inside the politics; doesn't pretend to neutrality.
Middle East EyeT1 · independentEnglish
Funded by
Donor-funded; widely reported as having received Qatari government support, though editorially independent.
Owned by
M.E.E. Ltd. (London-based)
PIELondon-based regional desk for Middle East reportage. Editorial independence is established; PIE includes the funding note in /sources for transparency, but applies no in-line mark.
ReasonT2 · declared consEnglish
Funded by
Reason Foundation (501c3); donor-supported.
Owned by
Reason Foundation
PIELibertarian editorial line, declared. Charles Koch family among historical donors.
Responsible StatecraftT2 · declared progEnglish
Funded by
Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft (501c3); donor-supported across Soros (Open Society) and Koch foundations.
Owned by
Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft
PIEAnti-interventionist realist line; explicitly cross-partisan funding (Open Society + Charles Koch). Closest thing to a Walt-school masthead in PIE's mix.
TangleT1 · independent
Explicitly bipartisan steelmanning newsletter. Wildcard — useful both as content and as a calibration reference for PIE's own steelmen.
The American ConservativeT2 · declared consEnglish
Funded by
Reader-funded; published by The American Ideas Institute (501c3).
Owned by
American Ideas Institute
PIEDeclares a paleoconservative / non-interventionist editorial line. Founded 2002 around skepticism of the post-Cold-War consensus on trade and intervention.
The AtlanticT1 · independent
Liberal-institutionalist framing. Longform analysis rather than hot takes.
ROLE 03Adversarial source

State-controlled outlets covering stories where their government is a party. They are not independent reporting. They are useful exactly because they speak for the state.

If the story is the Iran nuclear talks, you should know what Tehran is saying for the record. Tehran Times is the official line; we surface it so you don't have to imagine it. We rewrite their attribution — "Iran's official framing, via Tehran Times" — because the sentence is the truth, and a small badge isn't.

Outlets PIE reads in this role
Tehran TimesT3 · Iran stateEnglish (also Farsi via parent)
Funded by
State-funded.
Owned by
Mehr News Agency (Iranian state).
PIEIran's English-language paper of record for foreign audiences. PIE shows it to surface Iran's declared framing — not as independent reporting.
What you won't find here

We don't rank outlets. We don't show "trust scores." We don't mark some as "verified." Trust scores imply commensurability — that you can put The Atlantic and Tehran Times on the same axis. You can't. They're doing different things. PIE's job is to tell you which thing; the weighting is yours.